Back to Library

Speculation as a Fine Art and Thoughts on Life

by Dickson G. Watts (1880)

Quick summary -- an in-depth PhD-level extended summary (10-30 pages) for this book is coming soon.

Speculation as a Fine Art and Thoughts on Life

By Dickson G. Watts

Quick Summary

A timeless classic by Dickson G. Watts, President of the New York Cotton Exchange (1878-1880), distilling the fundamental principles of successful speculation into concise, universal laws. The book combines practical trading rules with philosophical aphorisms on life, business, society, and language, offering wisdom that remains relevant to modern traders and investors.

Executive Summary

"Speculation as a Fine Art and Thoughts on Life" is a brief but profoundly influential work originally published in the late 19th century by Dickson G. Watts, a successful speculator and President of the New York Cotton Exchange. The book is divided into two main sections: a treatise on the principles of speculation, and a collection of aphoristic observations on life, business, society, and language. Despite its brevity, it has been cited as "the bible for successful speculators" and was referenced extensively in Edwin Lefevre's "Reminiscences of a Stock Operator." The work establishes that speculation is not gambling but rather a venture based on calculation, and it articulates both absolute laws and conditional rules that govern successful speculative activity.

Core Thesis

Watts argues that speculation is a legitimate intellectual endeavor distinct from gambling, governed by identifiable laws and principles. The fundamental principle underlying all speculation is to "act so as to keep the mind clear, its judgment trustworthy." Success requires a rare combination of five essential qualities -- self-reliance, judgment, courage, prudence, and pliability -- maintained in careful balance. Only the "gifted man" can apply these rules successfully, making speculation as much an art as a science.

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis

Part I: Speculation as a Fine Art

What Is Speculation? Watts begins by distinguishing speculation from gambling. Speculation is "a venture based upon calculation," while gambling is "a venture without calculation." He argues that all business involves some speculation, but the term is typically reserved for ventures of exceptional uncertainty. He identifies five essential qualities for a speculator:

  1. Self-Reliance -- A speculator must think independently and follow personal convictions, as one cannot have another man's ideas.
  2. Judgment -- The balanced adjustment of faculties, enabling sound decision-making.
  3. Courage -- The confidence to act decisively on mental conclusions, following Mirabeau's dictum: "Be bold, still be bold; always be bold."
  4. Prudence -- The ability to measure danger with alertness. Prudence in contemplation, courage in execution.
  5. Pliability -- The ability to change opinions and revise positions when evidence warrants.

Laws Absolute These are inviolable principles:

  1. Never Overtrade -- Taking positions larger than capital justifies invites disaster. Over-interest unnerves the speculator, clouds judgment, and leads to poor decisions.
  2. Never "Double Up" -- When a position moves against you, adding to it is dangerous. This practice may work four times out of five, but the fifth time brings ruin.
  3. Run Quickly -- Act promptly at the first approach of danger, or if the moment is missed, hold on or reduce the position rather than panic.
  4. When Doubtful, Reduce the Interest -- If the mind is not satisfied with a position, or if the position is too large, reduce it to a "sleeping point."

Rules Conditional These are contextual guidelines:

  1. Better to Average Up Than Average Down -- Contrary to common practice, buying more on declines is dangerous because the fifth time may bring permanent decline and ruin. Instead, build positions as the market moves in your favor.
  2. Buying Down Requires Resources -- Only suitable for long-term investors with large capital and strong nerves who buy during depressions for general revivals.
  3. Stop Losses and Let Profits Run -- The fundamental rule. Failure to accept losses and eagerness to take profits prematurely is "the ruin of many."
  4. Respect Public Opinion -- Act cautiously with the crowd, boldly against it. The market has a pulse that must be read.
  5. Sell Quiet, Weak Markets; Buy Panics -- Quiet weakness tends to develop into decline; panic selling creates buying opportunities. Excitement signals selling opportunities.
  6. Allow for Chance -- Napoleon allowed a margin for accidents in his calculations. "Calculation must measure the incalculable."

Part II: Thoughts on Life

A collection of aphorisms organized into sections on Life, Business, Men, Society, and Language. Key themes include:

  • The importance of self-knowledge and humility
  • The dangers of excess and imbalance
  • The value of observation, discussion, and revision of opinions
  • The relationship between courage and wisdom
  • The cyclical nature of all movements in life and markets

Part III: Business

Practical observations on business success, emphasizing short-term views, imagination, adaptability, and the importance of managing losses rather than chasing profits. Notable maxim: "Take care of the losses; the profits will take care of themselves."

Key Concepts and Frameworks

  1. Speculation vs. Gambling -- The intellectual distinction that separates calculated risk-taking from blind chance.
  2. The Five Qualities -- Self-reliance, judgment, courage, prudence, and pliability as the essential traits of a speculator.
  3. Absolute Laws vs. Conditional Rules -- A hierarchy of trading principles, some inviolable, others context-dependent.
  4. The Sleeping Point -- A practical concept for position sizing: reduce exposure until you can sleep soundly.
  5. Averaging Up vs. Averaging Down -- A contrarian insight that adding to winners is safer than adding to losers.
  6. Market Pulse -- The idea that markets have a rhythm that can be read by experienced operators.

Practical Applications for Traders

  1. Position Sizing -- Never take a position so large that market fluctuations destroy your ability to think clearly. The "sleeping point" concept remains one of the most practical risk management tools ever articulated.
  2. Trend Following -- The advice to average up rather than down anticipates modern trend-following methodology by over a century.
  3. Contrarian Timing -- Buy during panics, sell during excitement. Act boldly against public opinion when conviction is strong.
  4. Loss Management -- "Run quickly" at the first sign of danger. Stop losses and let profits run.
  5. Mental Discipline -- The overarching principle of maintaining mental clarity above all else.

Critical Assessment

Strengths

  • Extraordinary brevity and clarity; every sentence carries weight
  • Principles that have stood the test of over 140 years
  • The emphasis on psychology and mental discipline anticipates modern trading psychology by a century
  • The hierarchical framework of absolute laws and conditional rules provides a practical decision-making structure

Limitations

  • Extremely brief; lacks detailed examples or case studies
  • The aphoristic style, while elegant, can be vague in practical application
  • Written for exchange-traded commodities speculation; some specific mechanics are outdated
  • No quantitative framework; entirely qualitative and philosophical

Historical Significance

This work is one of the earliest systematic treatments of speculative principles. Its influence can be traced through Jesse Livermore, Edwin Lefevre, and virtually all subsequent literature on trading psychology and risk management. The "Thoughts on Life" section reveals Watts as a deeply philosophical thinker whose observations on human nature inform and enrich his trading principles.

Key Quotes

  • "Speculation is a venture based upon calculation. Gambling is a venture without calculation."
  • "Act so as to keep the mind clear, its judgment trustworthy."
  • "Never Overtrade."
  • "The rule is to stop losses and let profits run."
  • "Sell down to a sleeping point."
  • "It is better to 'average up' than to 'average down.'"
  • "Act cautiously with public opinion; against it, boldly."
  • "Take care of the losses; the profits will take care of themselves."
  • "Not how much can you make, but how much can you lose."
  • "Thought and act should be hyphened."

Conclusion

Dickson G. Watts' slim volume remains one of the most concentrated expressions of trading wisdom ever written. Its power lies not in novel techniques or complex strategies but in its distillation of universal principles governing human behavior under uncertainty. The book's central insight -- that successful speculation requires maintaining mental clarity and emotional equilibrium above all else -- continues to be the foundation upon which all modern trading psychology rests. For a work written in the 1880s, its principles have proven remarkably durable, speaking to the unchanging nature of human psychology in markets.