Back to Library

Way of the Turtle: The Secret Methods that Turned Ordinary People into Legendary Traders

by Curtis M. Faith (2007)

Quick summary -- an in-depth PhD-level extended summary (10-30 pages) for this book is coming soon.

Way of the Turtle: The Secret Methods that Turned Ordinary People into Legendary Traders

Author: Curtis M. Faith | Categories: Trading Systems, Trend Following, Risk Management, Trading Psychology

Executive Summary

"Way of the Turtle" by Curtis M. Faith is the authoritative insider account of the legendary Turtle trading experiment conducted by Richard Dennis and William Eckhardt in 1983-1988. Dennis, one of the most successful commodity traders of his era, bet Eckhardt that trading could be taught to ordinary people, recruited traders through newspaper ads, and gave them his own money to trade. Faith, selected at age 19, became the most successful Turtle, trading the largest account and earning over $31 million for Dennis. The book reveals not just the Turtle trading rules (which Faith had previously published separately) but the deeper principles underlying their success: thinking in probabilities, maintaining emotional discipline during drawdowns, understanding edge, and designing robust trading systems that are not curve-fitted to historical data.

Core Thesis & Arguments

Faith's central thesis is that successful trading is not about prediction but about trading with an edge and managing risk systematically. Key arguments: (1) Trading can be taught, as the Turtle experiment proved, but the critical factor is whether students can follow the rules under pressure; (2) An "edge" is a statistical advantage that makes a trading system profitable over many trades, and identifying genuine edge requires understanding the sources of market inefficiency; (3) The biggest challenge in trading is not finding a system but executing it consistently through inevitable drawdowns; (4) Most backtested trading systems fail in live trading because they are overfit to historical data; (5) Risk management through position sizing (the Turtle's ATR-based "N" system) is the primary determinant of long-term survival; (6) Trend following works because human cognitive biases create persistent trends that systematic traders can exploit.

Chapter-by-Chapter Analysis

Chapters 1-3: The Turtle Story

Covers the genesis of the Turtle experiment, the selection process, the initial training, and Faith's first major trade - a live trade during training that made him $2 million. Establishes the psychological challenges of trading large positions at a young age.

Chapter 4: Think Like a Turtle

Introduces the key mental frameworks: trading in the present, thinking in probabilities, avoiding outcome bias, and focusing on the process rather than individual trade results.

Chapters 5-6: Trading with an Edge / Falling Off the Edge

Defines what constitutes a genuine trading edge, how to identify it, and why edges decay over time as markets adapt. Discusses the cognitive biases (recency, anchoring, outcome bias) that prevent traders from maintaining their edge.

Chapters 7-8: Measurement and Risk Management

Covers performance measurement (RAR%, R-cubed, Sharpe ratio), the critical difference between expectation and variance, and the Turtle's ATR-based position sizing system that limited risk to predefined levels.

Chapters 9-10: System Building Blocks and Step-by-Step Trading

Details the components of trend-following systems (entries, exits, stops, position sizing) and walks through the Turtle system step by step, including the Donchian channel breakout entries, ATR-based stops, and pyramiding rules.

Chapters 11-12: Backtesting Pitfalls and Robust Systems

Addresses the critical problems of curve fitting, data mining, optimization, and the difference between in-sample and out-of-sample testing. Presents principles for designing systems that are robust across different market conditions.

Chapters 13-14: Bulletproof Systems and Mastering Your Demons

Discusses how to build systems that survive changing market conditions and addresses the psychological challenges of following a system through extended losing periods.

Bonus Chapter: Original Turtle Trading Rules

Provides the complete, detailed Turtle trading rules as originally taught by Dennis, including entry rules, exit rules, position sizing formulas, and market selection criteria.

Key Concepts & Frameworks

  • The Edge: A statistical advantage derived from market inefficiencies that makes a system profitable over many trades
  • ATR-Based Position Sizing: Using Average True Range to normalize position sizes across different markets and volatility regimes
  • Donchian Channel Breakouts: Entering trades when price exceeds the highest high or lowest low of a specified lookback period
  • Robust vs. Curve-Fitted Systems: Systems that work across diverse conditions versus those that are overfit to specific historical data
  • R-Cubed (Risk-Adjusted Return): Faith's metric for evaluating system performance relative to risk taken
  • Cognitive Biases in Trading: Recency bias, anchoring, outcome bias, and loss aversion as obstacles to systematic trading
  • Pyramiding: Adding to winning positions as the trade moves in the desired direction

Practical Trading Applications

  • Use ATR-based position sizing to normalize risk across different markets and volatility environments
  • Enter trend-following positions on channel breakouts with confirmation filters
  • Limit total portfolio risk by capping the number of simultaneously correlated positions
  • Validate trading systems through out-of-sample testing and Monte Carlo simulation
  • Design systems with few parameters to minimize the risk of curve fitting
  • Maintain discipline through drawdowns by understanding that losing periods are mathematically inevitable
  • Pyramid into winning positions to maximize returns on successful trends

Critical Assessment

Strengths: Faith's insider perspective on the Turtle experiment is invaluable and cannot be replicated by any other author. The book goes well beyond the Turtle rules to provide a comprehensive education in systematic trading, covering edge, risk management, system design, and psychology. The chapters on backtesting pitfalls are among the best available anywhere, addressing problems that most trading books ignore entirely.

Weaknesses: Faith's personal narrative sometimes overshadows the educational content. The Turtle rules, while historically significant, are well-known and may no longer work as effectively in modern markets dominated by algorithmic trading. Some readers may find the book's organization somewhat scattered, with philosophy and technique interspersed unevenly. Faith's post-Turtle career was less distinguished than his Turtle performance, which some readers may find undermines his authority.

Key Quotes

  • "Good trading is not about being right, it's about trading right."
  • "The secret of trading is that there is no secret."
  • "The Turtles were not taught complex systems. They were taught simple systems and the discipline to follow them."

Conclusion & Recommendation

"Way of the Turtle" is essential reading for anyone interested in systematic trading, trend following, or trading system design. Faith's unique perspective as the most successful Turtle provides authenticity that no outside observer could replicate. The book's greatest value lies not in the specific Turtle rules but in the deeper lessons about edge, risk management, robustness, and the psychology of following a system. Recommended for all traders interested in systematic approaches, with particular value for those designing and backtesting their own trading systems.