Back to Library

The Aftershock Investor: A Crash Course in Staying Afloat in a Sinking Economy

by David Wiedemer, Robert A. Wiedemer, and Cindy S. Spitzer (2012)

Quick summary -- an in-depth PhD-level extended summary (10-30 pages) for this book is coming soon.

The Aftershock Investor: A Crash Course in Staying Afloat in a Sinking Economy

By David Wiedemer, Robert A. Wiedemer, and Cindy S. Spitzer

Quick Summary

A contrarian investment guide arguing that the U.S. economy is a multi-bubble system (real estate, stocks, private debt, government debt, dollar, discretionary spending) that is in the process of sequentially popping. Provides an alternative investment framework focused on gold, TIPS, and defensive positioning for investors who believe conventional wisdom based on the past will fail in a falling-bubble economy.

Executive Summary

The Wiedemer brothers and Cindy Spitzer, who claim to have predicted the 2008 financial crisis in their earlier book "America's Bubble Economy," argue that the crash was only the beginning of a larger multi-bubble collapse. Their thesis is that the U.S. economy has been inflated by six interconnected bubbles: real estate, stocks, private debt, government debt, the dollar, and discretionary spending. While the first bubbles (real estate, some stocks) have partially popped, they argue the remaining bubbles (especially government debt and the dollar) will eventually collapse, creating an "aftershock" that will devastate conventional investment portfolios.

Core Thesis

The future is NOT the past. Conventional investment wisdom assumes historical patterns will continue: stocks always go up over the long term, real estate recovers, bonds are safe, and the dollar maintains its value. The authors argue these assumptions are based on an anomalous period of bubble-fueled growth that is ending. In a falling-bubble economy, conventional portfolios (60/40 stocks/bonds) will fail, and investors need a fundamentally different approach centered on gold, short-term government securities, and strategic positioning for a deflationary/inflationary environment.

Key Content

The book systematically challenges conventional wisdom on each major asset class (stocks, bonds, real estate, insurance/annuities), presents the case for gold as a primary defensive asset, and provides practical portfolio construction guidance for what they term "aftershock investors." It also covers job/business strategy, retirement planning, and estate planning in the context of their macroeconomic thesis.

Critical Assessment

Strengths

  • Provides a coherent alternative macro framework for investors concerned about systemic risks
  • Systematic challenge to conventional investment assumptions is intellectually useful even for those who disagree
  • Practical portfolio guidance for defensive positioning
  • The multi-bubble framework is a useful analytical tool

Limitations

  • The most dire predictions have not materialized in the years since publication
  • The thesis has a permabear quality that can lead to missed opportunities in rising markets
  • Gold-centric investment advice has been mixed in practice
  • Some critics argue the authors' 2008 prediction was not as specific as claimed

Conclusion

"The Aftershock Investor" provides a valuable contrarian perspective for investors concerned about systemic risks in the global financial system. While its most extreme predictions should be treated with appropriate skepticism, the intellectual framework of questioning assumptions about perpetual economic growth and conventional portfolio construction is valuable for any investor's risk assessment toolkit.